Saturday, November 17, 2018
FSU Seminoles

Why FSU playing Boise State in Jacksonville is a smart risk

Old, unofficial news is expected to become old, official news today with a formal announcement that Florida State and Boise State are kicking off the 2019 season in Jacksonville.  

A lot has changed since the schools announced the series (FSU plays at Boise in 2020) five years ago. It looks like a risky move for the Seminoles, but I think it's a good one.

Some of the risks are obvious. Boise State is a very successful program. Just ask Virginia Tech (which lost  to the Broncos in 2010), Georgia (which lost to them in 2011) or Washington (which lost to them in 2015). FSU could be the next big-name program Boise slays.

Some of the risks are a little more nuanced, like this one: All 16 College Football Playoff participants have played at least one Power Five non-conference opponent. Boise doesn't fit that bill.

RELATED: College football's new motto: Go big early, or stay home late

FSU will still have one marquee Power Five non-conference opponent on its schedule (rival Florida). But the four ACC teams that have made the Playoff all had at least two of those games. If the ACC regresses and Boise is mediocre, FSU risks having a weak schedule that could hurt its ultimate goal of making the Playoff.

The gamble is worth taking, though, because you need to do more than schedule tough opponents to make the final four. You need to beat them.

Of the 16 Playoff participants so far, 15 of them beat their Power Five non-conference opponent (Ohio State losing to Virginia Tech in 2014 is the exception). Playing Oklahoma didn't help the Buckeyes get in last year. Why? Because they lost to the Sooners and got crushed by Iowa. No two-loss team has made the Playoff yet.

Even though Boise State isn't in a Power Five conference, it provides the opportunity for FSU to play, and beat, a tough opponent. The Broncos are a respected program. The selection committee looks at top-25 wins; the Broncos finished 25th last year in its final rankings, ahead of 10 ACC schools and FSU's marquee opponent in 2020 (West Virginia). The committee might undervalue Group of Five programs — right, UCF fans? — but it doesn't completely dismiss them, either. Beat a good Boise team, and you'll get respect from pollsters and the committee.

And despite Boise's history of upsets, FSU should beat Boise. The Seminoles will have more talent. More talent doesn't always win, but it usually does. The talent gap between FSU and Boise is bigger than the gap between, say, FSU and Ole Miss (its 2016 opening opponent) or FSU and LSU (who opens against Miami this year). That means Boise seems more winnable than other big-name opponents, but the Broncos are still a recognized name that would boost FSU's strength of schedule.

I'm not going to make predictions about a game that's more than 15 months away, or about FSU's 2019 season before it plays this fall. But the soon-to-be-official Jacksonville game against Boise State gives the Seminoles a respected non-conference opponent it should be favored to beat in a talent-rich recruiting area full of FSU fans and boosters. Seems like a good idea to me.

Comments
The end of ‘The Streak’ would be another sorry chapter for Florida State

The end of ‘The Streak’ would be another sorry chapter for Florida State

Florida State's run of 36 consecutive bowl games, which began under Bobby Bowden, might screech to a halt this afternoon under Willie Taggart
Updated: 12 hours ago
Hot seat watch, coaches in contention to move up, Jimbo Fisher flashback and more college football notes

Hot seat watch, coaches in contention to move up, Jimbo Fisher flashback and more college football notes

Yes, Skip Holtz flopped at USF, but he's doing very well at Louisiana Tech...
Published: 11/16/18
Who has been more disappointing: Florida State or Miami?

Who has been more disappointing: Florida State or Miami?

Times columnist Martin Fennelly and writer Matt Baker discuss which former powerhouse has had a worse 2018.
Published: 11/14/18
25 things about No. 1 FSU vs. No. 2 Notre Dame, 25 years later

25 things about No. 1 FSU vs. No. 2 Notre Dame, 25 years later

We rewatched one of the games of the century to see Charlie Ward, Warrick Dunn, Derrick Brooks, Skip Holtz and O.J. Simpson.
Published: 11/09/18
AP sources: Injured quarterback Ian Book to miss Notre Dame’s game against Florida State

AP sources: Injured quarterback Ian Book to miss Notre Dame’s game against Florida State

No. 3 Notre Dame will start quarterback Brandon Wimbush against Florida State on Saturday for Ian Book, who is nursing an undisclosed injury, two people familiar with the decision told The Associated Press. Book is not expected to play after taking a...
Published: 11/08/18
Joe Henderson: Athletic departments need to heed the warnings of dwindling attendance

Joe Henderson: Athletic departments need to heed the warnings of dwindling attendance

UF becomes the latest football program to see a decline at the gate.
Published: 11/06/18
Florida State suspends two players for first half vs. N.C. State

Florida State suspends two players for first half vs. N.C. State

TALLAHASSEE — Florida State will be without leading receiver Nyqwan Murray and reserve linebacker Zaquandre White for the first half of Saturday’s game at North Carolina State. Coach Willie Taggart announced the suspensions on Monday. Murray and Whi...
Updated one month ago
Florida State journal: Mental mistakes, then a meltdown

Florida State journal: Mental mistakes, then a meltdown

TALLAHASSEE — The first quarter against Clemson was scoreless, and early in the second, Florida State held the Tigers to a 40-yard field-goal attempt, which soared wide right.Against the No. 2 team in the nation, a still scoreless game was some...
Updated one month ago
Florida State matches worst margin of defeat in 59-10 loss to No. 2 Clemson

Florida State matches worst margin of defeat in 59-10 loss to No. 2 Clemson

TALLAHASSEE — Big stops from the Florida State defense and early Clemson miscues gave the Seminoles offense plenty of time to get going in the first quarter Saturday. The Seminoles forced the No. 2-ranked Tigers to punt on their first three pos...
Updated one month ago
Ocala couple pledges $20 million for FSU football facility

Ocala couple pledges $20 million for FSU football facility

OCALA — Al and Judy Dunlap have assembled a family compound over the years.There's the lake house, and the farm house, and the main home, all surrounded by horse pastures and guarded by an army of animal statues.Soon enough, the Florida State f...
Updated one month ago