Wednesday, March 21, 2018

Legally, St. Pete mayoral race is nonpartisan. Truthfully, party matters

ST. PETERSBURG — The job of mayor, Rick Kriseman said in a 2013 video announcing his candidacy in St. Petersburg, is to be a problem solver. "And best of all, unlike those in Tallahassee and Washington, it's a job where policy takes precedence over partisanship."

Fast-forward to this year when Mayor Kriseman, an underdog for re-election, rarely misses an opportunity to remind St. Pete voters that he is a Democrat and his main challenger, former Mayor Rick Baker, is a Republican. Last month, Kriseman had the chance to ask Baker any question in the world during their only televised debate.

"I was working and fighting to get then-Sen. Barack Obama elected president (in 2008)," Kriseman said. "At the time you were mayor of the city of St. Petersburg and you were working and trying to see that Sen. Obama wasn't elected. You made a comment, you said that Sarah 'Drill baby, drill' Palin would be a great vice president. So would you explain why you felt she would make a great vice president?"

Baker calls that an inconsequential and petty line of attack. Kriseman says it's a straight-forward question to illustrate Baker's values and underlying ideology.

Fair on both counts, but party does tell us plenty about a candidate, and pretending it should be ignored or off limits in a campaign is absurd.

Legally, municipal elections in Florida are nonpartisan. Not so many years ago, few St. Pete residents could identify the party registration of their mayor.

That period effectively ended in 2001 when Baker, in his first campaign for mayor, invited Gov. Jeb Bush to headline a fundraiser in St. Petersburg a few weeks after the Supreme Court's Bush vs. Gore ruling.

The mayoral candidates' party affiliations are not listed on ballots, but expecting voters to ignore party is as naive as expecting them to tune out negative ads.

"Anyone who has ever knocked on a door for a campaign, in either party, in the last 15 years will tell you it is the first or second question the person answering the door asks," said St. Petersburg City Council member Charlie Gerdes, a Democrat and Kriseman supporter.

Urban reformers in the early 20th century pressed for nonpartisan elections under the theory that fixing potholes and installing sewer lines are nonpartisan issues, and party machines breed corruption.

Darryl Paulson, who taught politics and urban government for nearly 35 years at the University of South Florida St. Petersburg, said that dubious premise made even less sense in the 1990s as mid-sized cities like St. Petersburg moved from governments led by city managers to full-time "strong mayors" running day-to-day city operations.

Paulson thinks Florida law should be changed to allow partisan city elections.

"What you end up with is a situation where everyone knows the partisan affiliation of the candidates, but it is illegal to conduct partisan local elections," Paulson said. "Stop making both citizens and candidates pretend that local elections are nonpartisan."

That Baker wants to downplay party affiliation and Kriseman wants to emphasize it is a no-brainer.

Like many decent-sized cities, St. Petersburg is progressive and Democratic-leaning. Only a third of voters picking the next mayor are Republican, and nearly 60 percent of the city's voters backed Hillary Clinton over Donald Trump last year.

Baker, who has long seen himself as a rising star in statewide GOP politics, won't even say whether he voted for Trump.

"Rick Baker is on the extreme team — siding with climate change deniers, silent on Donald Trump's countless discriminatory policies," says a female narrator in the Florida Democratic Party's latest TV ad for Kriseman, showing images of Baker with Trump, Rick Scott and Mitt Romney.

At a time when the GOP controls Washington and Tallahassee, cities are the last bastion of Democratic political strength in Florida. Both parties understand that who holds high-profile, elective offices in the biggest battleground region of America's biggest battleground state has repercussions beyond local water rates.

That's a big reason why Kriseman recently won the coveted endorsement of the Rev. Louis Murphy, pastor of Mount Zion Progressive Missionary Baptist Church, the largest African-American congregation in the city.

"Now more than ever, it is critical that we elect leaders like Rick Kriseman who will stand up to attacks from Tallahassee and Washington, and continue fighting for our community," Murphy said.

Democratic School Board member Rene Flowers, who four years ago supported Republican Bill Foster for mayor and this year supports Kriseman, said Baker can't on the one hand tout his commitment to a "seamless city" serving all residents well, while at the same time supporting a party where leaders are eager to eliminate health care coverage for thousands of city residents.

Brian Hughes, a Republican consultant who works with Jacksonville Mayor Lenny Curry, thinks the whole debate over partisanship in city elections is nonsense.

"A pothole may not belong to a party, but the philosophy of the person in charge of fixing it matters," Hughes said. "If the candidate is a labor-endorsed Democrat, their idea of how city services are managed is likely different than a pro-business, conservative Republican. Why wouldn't those philosophies and the ways they will influence leadership be a factor?"

Most of us prefer nonpartisanship at City Hall.

"What has partisanship gotten us on the national level but gridlock?" asked Darden Rice, a St. Petersburg City Council member, Democrat and Kriseman supporter, adding that Baker made party affiliation fair game by campaigning for high-profile Republicans.

Tampa Mayor Bob Buckhorn, another Democrat and Kriseman supporter, noted that party affiliation tends to "rear its ugly head" more in campaigns for local office than in governing but still is far less important than in campaigns for partisan offices like Congress or the Legislature.

"The connection between a mayor and the people who hire him or her is a very different one than it is for other offices," Buckhorn said. "It is far more personal. People are better versed on the personalities in a mayor's race. They know the personalities. They interact with them."

This point explains why Baker, a well-known Republican, is the front-runner in St. Petersburg's mayoral race.

No mayor in modern history has won election without strong support from the city's overwhelmingly Democratic African-American voters, and Baker is better known among black voters than Kriseman. His long-term effectiveness can be debated, but his commitment and attention to Midtown and other heavily black neighborhoods cannot.

An automated poll of 862 city voters conducted Aug. 7 found Baker and Kriseman tied among African-American voters, despite Kriseman doing all he can to remind voters that Baker is a Republican. That St. Pete Polls survey should be taken with a grain of salt because it does not reach voters who use only cellphones, but it also showed Baker winning 30 percent of Democrats and Kriseman just 16 percent of Republicans.

"Party affiliation does not factor in on the ballot, and what I want for my city is the best possible candidate," said Democratic former City Council member and state Rep. Frank Peterman, who endorsed Baker.

"Rick Baker has proven himself through the prior time he served as mayor. He did a good job for the entire city, especially for the African-American community."

Kriseman has aggressively pursued plenty of policies to promote his and the city's progressive image: no longer requiring job seekers to reveal prior criminal convictions; finally adopting curbside recycling; moving to thwart chain stores on Central Avenue; enthusiastically promoting the city's big Pride festival; and vowing to adhere to the Paris climate agreement.

If Kriseman loses re-election, it won't be for lack of living up to Democratic ideals. It will be because he did not pay sufficient attention to the fundamentals, especially the city's sewage system. And it will show he was right in that campaign kickoff announcement more than four years ago.

In local government, policy takes precedence over partisanship.

Contact Adam C. Smith at Follow @adamsmithtimes.

Federal Reserve hikes interest rate to highest level in a decade amid stronger economy

Federal Reserve hikes interest rate to highest level in a decade amid stronger economy

The Federal Reserve on Wednesday lifted its key interest rate from 1.5 percent to 1.75 percent, the highest level since 2008.The move, the central bank’s first major decision under new Chairman Jerome Powell, was widely expected as the U.S. economy c...
Updated: 11 hours ago
Lawyers for Stormy Daniels, Michael Cohen erupt at each other: ‘You’re gonna go down in flames’

Lawyers for Stormy Daniels, Michael Cohen erupt at each other: ‘You’re gonna go down in flames’

The ever-escalating Stormy Daniels saga took another strange turn Tuesday night when CNN brought attorneys for the porn star and Michael Cohen, President Donald Trump’s longtime personal lawyer, into its studios and let them rip into each other on pr...
Published: 03/21/18
Trump rails against Mueller investigation, dismisses McCabe’s notes as ‘Fake Memos’

Trump rails against Mueller investigation, dismisses McCabe’s notes as ‘Fake Memos’

WASHINGTON — President Donald Trump fired off angry tweets Sunday morning railing against the Justice Department special counsel’s Russia investigation and attacking the integrity of former FBI director James B. Comey and his former deputy, Andrew Mc...
Published: 03/18/18
Trump lawyer says special counsel inquiry should be ended

Trump lawyer says special counsel inquiry should be ended

WASHINGTON — A lawyer for President Donald Trump called on the Justice Department on Saturday to end the special counsel investigation into ties between Russia and the Trump campaign, shifting abruptly to a more adversarial stance as the inquiry appe...
Published: 03/17/18

Trump-linked data analysis firm taps 50M Facebook profiles

WASHINGTON — A data analysis firm employed by President Donald Trump’s 2016 campaign tapped the Facebook profiles of more than 50 million users without their permission, allowing it to capitalize on the private social media activity of a large portio...
Published: 03/17/18

Lawmakers quibble over details of $1.3T U.S. spending bill

WASHINGTON — Top-level congressional talks on a $1.3 trillion catchall spending bill are reaching a critical stage as negotiators confront immigration, abortion-related issues and a battle over a massive rail project that pits President Donald Trump ...
Published: 03/17/18
Former FBI agent Fred Humphries calls McCabe firing justified

Former FBI agent Fred Humphries calls McCabe firing justified

Fred Humphries woke up Saturday morning and for the first time ever raised a blue and white Federal Bureau of Investigation flag on the pole in his front yard."I was encouraged and hopeful," said Humphries, 53, in an exclusive interview with the Tamp...
Published: 03/17/18
Trump’s lawyer calls on Justice Department to immediately end Russia probe

Trump’s lawyer calls on Justice Department to immediately end Russia probe

President Donald Trump’s lawyer called on the Justice Department to immediately shut down the special counsel probe into Russian interference in the 2016 election, in the wake of the firing of FBI Deputy Director Andrew McCabe.Attorney John Dowd said...
Published: 03/17/18
Like James Comey, fired deputy director McCabe kept personal memos regarding Trump

Like James Comey, fired deputy director McCabe kept personal memos regarding Trump

WASHINGTON — Andrew McCabe, the onetime FBI deputy director long scorned by President Trump and just fired by the attorney general, kept personal memos regarding Trump that are similar to the notes compiled by dismissed FBI chief James Comey detailin...
Published: 03/17/18
Sarah Palin headlines event at Trump’s Mar-a-Lago Club

Sarah Palin headlines event at Trump’s Mar-a-Lago Club

PALM BEACH, - If they came to see the president, they were disappointed. But the well-dressed crowd of Republican activists who gathered at President Donald Trump’s Mar-a-Lago Club here Friday night still got a glimpse of party royalty.There by the p...
Published: 03/17/18