Thursday, July 19, 2018
Columns

PolitiFact Florida: Andrew Gillum’s largely accurate attack on Philip Levine’s record

As he makes his run to become Florida’s governor, Democrat Philip Levine often touts the more progressive moves he made during his time as mayor of Miami Beach.

Chief among them is increasing the minimum wage and banning assault weapons.

"Everyone wants to tell you what they’re going to do in the future, but no one wants to tell you what they’ve done," Levine said June 9. "Well let me tell you what I’ve done as mayor: I raised the minimum living wage in the city of Miami Beach, and I plan to do it statewide. We actually decriminalized marijuana. We’ve had the highest LGBTQ scores in the entire state of Florida. We became the leading poster child on sea-level rise and climate change and by the way, we banned assault rifles."

But one of Levine’s opponents in 2018 Democratic primary says Levine’s achievements aren’t as successful as he sometimes makes it seem.

"They passed a resolution to ban assault rifles, which was not enforceable and never enforced," said Tallahassee Mayor Andrew Gillum. "(Philip Levine) passed a resolution to raise the minimum wage, which actually no one got the benefit of because it was not enforced."

Gillum’s claim is largely accurate. Miami Beach passed a resolution urging lawmakers to adopt an assault rifle ban, but it wasn’t a ban. It was a resolution that carried no legal authority. As for the minimum wage increase, Miami Beach passed an ordinance to gradually increase it to $13.31 per hour by 2021, but it was struck down by the courts before it went into effect.

On July 13, 2016, Miami Beach commissioners adopted a resolution urging Congress and the Florida Legislature to lobby for assault weapons bans. It also urged the Florida Legislature to lift the pre-emption policy that prevents local governments from enacting gun control ordinances.

The resolution had no legal authority, though. That’s because resolutions, according to the Florida Statutes, are a statement of position, not an official legislative action of a governing body like a law.

"A resolution of the city commission of the city of Miami Beach, Florida, calling upon the federal and state-elected officials to collaborate with local officials and first responders to prevent mass shootings …," the resolution heading says.

So rather than an actual ban, the resolution was really more of a call to action for lawmakers to consider banning assault weapons. It did not impede Miami Beach residents’ access to them.

The resolution wouldn’t have survived. Under Florida law, any local officials who try to enact gun regulations that are more restrictive than state law face fines up to $5,000 or even removal from office. Florida cities, including Miami Beach, have sued Gov. Rick Scott so they can enact tougher local gun regulations.

As we mentioned, Levine sometimes touts this achievement with no additional clarifications, but at one point during the June 9 debate, Levine acknowledged that the assault weapons ban "wasn’t enforceable."

"As the mayor of Miami Beach we did many things," Levine said. "From reforming a police department from raising the minimum wage to fighting back sea level rise to decriminalizing marijuana to banning assault rifles even, though unfortunately, it was not enforceable."

In June 2016, Miami Beach commissioners voted to gradually raise the minimum wage in the city from $8.05 to $13.31 per hour by 2021. The increase would have been enforced basically starting January 2018 and gone up every year until reaching the 2021 threshold.

The law never went in to effect, though. Florida Circuit Court Judge Peter Lopez ruled in March 2017 that Miami Beach’s minimum wage law was pre-empted by a state statute preventing local minimum wages from exceeding the state rate.

A panel of the 3rd District Court of Appeal upheld Lopez’s ruling, but Miami Beach (along with other cities) asked the Florida Supreme Court to review the Dec. 13 appellate court ruling.

So, Gillum is right that no one really got the benefit of it.

The one thing worth noting is that Gillum could have been more precise in describing the action Miami Beach took. Gillum said it was a resolution, but it was an ordinance. This means that the minimum wage increase, unlike the assault weapon resolution, would have been enforced had it not been struck down.

During the debate, Levine alluded to issues with the minimum wage effort.

"In 2004, the people of Florida voted that the local municipality should have the right to enforce and set their own minimum wage," Levine said. "That’s what we did. Unfortunately, we got sued by the governor, the state of Florida, the Retail Federation. We are fighting it in court and we believe it’s going to go to the Florida Supreme Court and we’re going to win. The fact of that matter is we did it."

Gillum said Levine "passed a resolution to ban assault rifles, which was not enforceable," and passed "a resolution to raise the minimum wage, which actually no one got the benefit of because it was not enforced."

We rate this claim Mostly True.

Read more rulings at PolitiFact.com/florida.

Comments
PolitiFact Florida: What Trump’s Supreme Court nominee Brett Kavanaugh has said on abortion

PolitiFact Florida: What Trump’s Supreme Court nominee Brett Kavanaugh has said on abortion

When President Donald Trump unveiled his second Supreme Court justice pick, Florida’s Democratic candidates for governor warned of dire consequences for access to abortion."With his pick of Brett Kavanaugh, President Trump has done everything in his ...
Published: 07/16/18
PolitiFact Florida: Did Sen. Bill Nelson vote for higher taxes 349 times? No

PolitiFact Florida: Did Sen. Bill Nelson vote for higher taxes 349 times? No

For years, Republicans have criticized Democratic Sen. Bill Nelson for voting to raise taxes again and again.Nelson’s opponent in the 2012 U.S. Senate race, Connie Mack, claimed Nelson raised taxes 150 times. That claim grew to 272 before the Novembe...
Published: 07/09/18
PolitiFact Florida: Andrew Gillum’s largely accurate attack on Philip Levine’s record

PolitiFact Florida: Andrew Gillum’s largely accurate attack on Philip Levine’s record

As he makes his run to become Florida’s governor, Democrat Philip Levine often touts the more progressive moves he made during his time as mayor of Miami Beach.Chief among them is increasing the minimum wage and banning assault weapons."Everyone want...
Updated one month ago
PolitiFact Florida: Republican PAC misleads in ad about Sen. Bill Nelson’s record on Social Security, Medicare

PolitiFact Florida: Republican PAC misleads in ad about Sen. Bill Nelson’s record on Social Security, Medicare

A new ad portrays Democratic Sen. Bill Nelson as a career politician who doesn’t have the backs of senior citizens.The New Republican PAC, which is backing Gov. Rick Scott in Florida’s closely watched Senate race, released a 30-second ad criticizing ...
Updated one month ago