Tuesday, July 17, 2018
News Roundup

Grounded: St. Pete City Council rejects Echelman’s aerial artwork

ST. PETERSBURG — One of artist Janet Echelman’s colorful, lighted aerial sculptures will not fly over the downtown waterfront — at least not yet.

The City Council on Thursday night voted down a $1.5 million contract to build the art project, rejecting the signature piece of public artwork Mayor Rick Kriseman had long sought to add to the city’s new Pier District.

The 4-3 vote was made after a 3½-hour discussion, as residents lined up to speak out in support of the project and against plans to install the large, billowing net sculpture at Spa Beach, which is protected by the city charter.

The council, though, sent city staff back to the drawing board and asked for a report to determine whether the sculpture could be moved to another location in the Pier District, or reoriented at Spa Beach.

TAMPA BAY TIMES COVERAGE: JANET ECHELMAN’S AERIAL ARTWORK

Questions, costs surround Janet Echelman’s art for St. Pete pier

Some fear Spa Beach billowing net sculpture could catch birds and storms

Parks Foundation opposes Echelman sculpture on Spa Beach

Mayor Kriseman: Donors will bring Echelman sculpture to St. Pete

Council members Gina Driscoll, Amy Foster, Steve Kornell and Ed Montanari all voted to reject the art project. Charlie Gerdes, Brandi Gabbard and Darden Rice voted for it. Member Lisa Wheeler-Bowman was not present for the discussion or vote.

About 30 people signed up to make their case to the council, speaking eloquently about nature and art. When council started its discussion, Driscoll signaled early on that she was going to vote no.

"Not because I don’t want this art," she said, adding that she felt there was room for a compromise about where the artwork could be installed.

Montanari explained why he voted against it.

"I know it’s vitally important for us to preserve what we were handed down," he said, recalling historic efforts to preserve the city’s scenic waterfront.

Gerdes said he was voting for the project because the chance to land one of Echelman’s sculptures, which have been installed across the world, would have cemented the city’s status as a center of art culture.

"I do not want to lose what to me is the unbelievable opportunity ...," he said. "I do not want to miss that moment."

Rice spoke of the century-old tradition of preserving the city’s waterfront parks. She said the goal of William Straub was to preserve green space, but that she believed it was meant to support human activity.

"To me, the fabric sculpture, the Echelman piece, if it is something that ultimately beckons our citizens, our visitors, young, old, black, white, if it beckons people to wander out into that part of Spa Beach ... to sit under the fabric, to think, reflect, connect ... I think that is consistent with the dream of what Straub had for St. Petersburg."

Kriseman echoed Rice’s words. He said he didn’t think that St. Petersburg’s founding fathers wanted its downtown parks to sit vacant.

Instead, he said, Echelman’s art would activate Spa Beach: "I think it’s an incredibly exciting possibility."

The day was won by opponents such as Marsha Kuhlman, who spoke before the vote. She lives downtown and co-founded a Facebook page, Save Spa Beach Park.

"Our organization has never been against the art. It’s location, location, location," said Phil Graham Jr., president of the Waterfront Parks Foundation, which has been fighting the Echelman project at Spa Beach.

Graham showed a PowerPoint that had a rendering his organization commissioned to illustrate what it believes would be an obstruction to downtown waterfront views.

Bob Carter, chair of the Community Planning and Preservation Commission, said the issue is one of the most important preservation matters he has encountered. Though he likes the Echelman piece, Carter said he was opposed to the Spa Beach location.

"The Public Arts Commission has been working on this for over two years," said Kathryn Howd, a commission member, adding that the Echelman sculpture would transform the urban park.

During Thursday’s meeting, B2 Communications principal Kyle Parks, who volunteered to boost the Echelman project, showed a video featuring supporters such as architect Tim Clemmons, Bob Devin Jones, artistic director of Studio@620, and well-known local artist Katee Tully.

"We are certainly hopeful that a resolution can be reached that can still bring a Janet Echelman sculpture to the Pier District," Parks said after the vote. "I think that in recent conversations that the city has had, the artist has shown a willingness to have some flexibility on things like size."

The controversy has pit those focused on protecting the city’s downtown waterfront parks against others who say parks should be part of a modern, urban environment.

Driscoll, whose district includes parts of downtown, summed up the problem hours earlier at a St. Petersburg Downtown Neighborhood Association meeting:

"This is an important decision that we will be making, because we have an opportunity to bring an extraordinary artist to our city. We also have a responsibility to preserve our waterfront and make sure that we plan in the best possible way what was intended by the founding fathers of our city.

"How do we get both, that’s the question. … How can we make sure that our waterfront and our arts tradition both move forward together in some way?"

The stalled project would cost $2.8 million. Kriseman had raised $1.3 million of that in private donations for the sculpture itself, with 14 groups of donors pledging money for the art. The city has budgeted $1.3 million in public funds to build the infrastructure. The Public Arts Commission had also pledged $250,000 to the project.

The contract would have allowed Echelman to start designing her net sculpture.

"The color hues and patterns I am considering for the fiber are inspired by the vibrantly patterned beach parasols seen on historical postcards, and these colored twines can be seen brightly against the blue sky in daytime," she said by email before Thursday’s meeting.

The current concept called for an aerial artwork that would stretch approximately 200 feet and be anchored by cables to five supporting poles, one at 60 feet, three 25 feet, one at 35 feet.

Chris Ballestra, the city’s managing director of development coordination, said this week that Echelman’s art, which he described as having "an undeniable wow factor" has "shrunk considerably" since its initial concept.

"And all of us are very happy with its size and scale relative to the project," he said.

The $76 million, 26-acre Pier District, currently under construction, is scheduled to be complete by fall 2019.

Contact Waveney Ann Moore at wmoore@tampabay.com or (727) 892-2283. Follow @wmooretimes.

Comments
Sports Day Tampa Bay podcast: Jimbo Fisher discusses Florida State, Jameis Winston

Sports Day Tampa Bay podcast: Jimbo Fisher discusses Florida State, Jameis Winston

Texas A&M head coach Jimbo Fisher was front and center Monday at SEC media days and spoke about leaving Florida State and why Jameis Winston will have no problem moving on from his suspension.Plus, Blake Snell might be the third AL pitcher ...
Updated: 2 minutes ago
Daughter accused in fatal beating of 85-year-old mother who didn’t include her in will

Daughter accused in fatal beating of 85-year-old mother who didn’t include her in will

Saying she was angry about being left without an inheritance, a Fort Lauderdale woman fatally beat her 85-year-old mother, police say.Gabriela Perero, 53, is facing charges of premeditated murder and aggravated battery on a person 65 years of age or ...
Updated: 7 minutes ago
Hillsborough to train school resource officers during active shooter exercise

Hillsborough to train school resource officers during active shooter exercise

DOVER — With the start of classes nearly three weeks away, Hillsborough County school resource officers will receive extensive active shooter training Tuesday morning to prepare them in the event of another school tragedy.Members of the Hillsborough ...
Updated: 21 minutes ago
PolitiFact: Fact-checking the Donald Trump-Vladimir Putin summit

PolitiFact: Fact-checking the Donald Trump-Vladimir Putin summit

President Donald Trump and President Vladimir Putin made inaccurate statements to the media following their one-on-one talks in Helsinki about election meddling, global terrorism and nuclear nonproliferation.Here’s a rundown of our fact-checks.Trump:...
Updated: 25 minutes ago
Blacks can afford far fewer rentals than Asians and whites, study shows

Blacks can afford far fewer rentals than Asians and whites, study shows

Black and Latino residents of the Tampa Bay area can afford far fewer rentals than Asians and whites can. According to Zillow, blacks can afford just 19 percent of available rentals and Latinos 20.7 percent. That compares to whites being able to affo...
Updated: 28 minutes ago
Hernando Sheriff: Two men charged in middle school laptop theft

Hernando Sheriff: Two men charged in middle school laptop theft

SPRING HILL — Two young men are in jail after admitting to stealing 19 laptops from Powell Middle School earlier this month, according to the Hernando County Sheriff’s Office.Justin Hopkins, 21, and Brandon Pestana, 22 — former students at the school...
Updated: 1 hour ago
Teacher on a plane talked about her low-income students. Passengers overheard and gave her more than $500 in cash.

Teacher on a plane talked about her low-income students. Passengers overheard and gave her more than $500 in cash.

Chicago schoolteacher Kimberly Bermudez has always been the chatty type.So when she was on a Southwest Airlines flight to Florida to visit her parents last week, and her seatmate asked her what she did for a living, she told him about her first-grade...
Updated: 1 hour ago
New Spring Hill funeral home offers dining, catering services for grieving families

New Spring Hill funeral home offers dining, catering services for grieving families

SPRING HILL — A new funeral home, in response to changing mores, is focused on serving the living, providing homelike conviviality and social amenities that reach beyond attention to death.Yvette and Jim Klausch, licensed funeral directors with 40 ye...
Updated: 1 hour ago
NFL player salaries: How much will the 2018 Tampa Bay Buccaneers make?

NFL player salaries: How much will the 2018 Tampa Bay Buccaneers make?

Here’s a look at what each player on the Tampa Bay Buccaneers is set to earn this season.Note that the amounts listed are “cash” figures, or the actual dollars a player will receive. In some cases, the cash a player earns will diffe...
Updated: 1 hour ago
Members new and old appointed to Pasco-Hernando State College boards

Members new and old appointed to Pasco-Hernando State College boards

Three trustees for Pasco-Hernando State College have been reappointed to their posts by Gov. Rick Scott, and a new member joined the college’s Foundation Board of Directors.The reappointments to the Board of Trustees are Alvaro Hernandez, Lee Maggard...
Updated: 1 hour ago