Friday, September 21, 2018
  • The Buzz
  • From the staff of the Tampa Bay Times

Why are Florida lawmakers trying to get rid of this one ethics rule?

On Friday afternoon, in the frantic final hours of the legislative session, Florida's Ethics Commission issued an extraordinary press release expressing "deep concern" and warning senators not to pass a bill that would have gutted part of the state's ethics rules.

The bill didn't pass, but commissioners are worried after lawmakers have tried three times in the last two years to get rid of an obscure ethics rule dealing with lawyers serving on city and county commissions.

Currently, ethics rules say a lawyer with the Gunster law firm representing a trash company, for example, can't go before a local board in which another Gunster lawyer is a member.

The reasons are obvious and irreconcilable, ethicists say. Even if the board member discloses the conflict of interests, the board member could still easily influence the outcome of a bid in other ways, by giving his law partner advice on how to influence the board, or by influencing county staff about the bid. Even the board member's presence could influence his or her fellow board members.

"No matter which way you turn it, it's just an inherent conflict," Ethics Commission Executive Director Virlindia Doss said Monday.

Nevertheless, lawyers in the Legislature are making a bipartisan effort to do away with the rule.

The example that prompted the ethics commission's warning came from Rep. Daniel Perez, a Republican lawyer from Miami who successfully amended a bill in the last week of session. His amendment allowed lawyers to present clients before boards in which their law partners sit, as long as the board member disclosed the conflict and didn't vote on it.

But Perez wasn't the only one. An hour before the ethics commission sent its press release, Sen. Perry Thurston, a lawyer and Democrat from Lauderhill, attached a word-for-word copy to another bill. He didn't respond to requests for comment.

Neither made it into law. Perez on Friday appeared confused as to why the ethics commission would be opposed to his amendment.

"I respect them, and I understand that they're doing what they believe is in their best interests," he said. "I'm not sure that they understand the amendment."

But they did understand the amendment, because they'd seen it before. In 2015, then-Sen. Don Gaetz tried to do it. And in the waning days of the 2017 session, Sen. Rob Bradley, a lawyer and Republican from Fleming Island, tried to slip a similar amendment into another bill.

His amendment prompted the Ethics Commission to warn lawmakers in August, in advance of the 2018 session, against changing the rule.

"The Commission is wrong on this issue," Bradley said in a text message on Monday. "Hopefully, the Legislature addresses this matter next session."

Stripping away the rule wouldn't just benefit local officials. More than one in five lawmakers is a lawyer, including House Speaker Richard Corcoran, who works for Broad & Cassell, and Senate President Joe Negron, who resigned from the Gunster law firm last year. Any or all could run for local office when they're term-limited out of the Legislature.

In its press release, ethics commissioners said they were adamantly against any changes to the rule.

“The Commission feels so strongly about the importance of this public protection that in its 2018 legislative recommendations it specifically requested that this precedent not be relaxed in any way,” the press release states.

Doss, the Ethics Commission executive director, said she could not remember commissioners ever issuing a press release advocating lawmakers vote one way or another on a bill.

"I think it really concerned them that in the last two years, this has come up as a floor amendment on the last few days of session," she said. "It does keep coming up again and again."

Comments
What did Ron DeSantis do during his tour in Iraq?

What did Ron DeSantis do during his tour in Iraq?

Way back on June 25, Ron DeSantis released his first TV ad as he faced off with Commissioner of Agriculture Adam Putnam for the Republican nomination for governor.His first words in the ad, as he introduced himself to Florida voters: "Ron DeSantis, I...
Updated: 2 hours ago
Andrew Gillum pays extra taxes on his Tallahassee home, records show

Andrew Gillum pays extra taxes on his Tallahassee home, records show

During his bid for governor, Democrat Andrew Gillum has reminded voters constantly that he isn't a millionaire like some of the other candidates who sought the office.But a review of property and tax records shows that Gillum is paying extra taxes wh...
Updated: 4 hours ago
In Senate 18 race, Janet Cruz says Dana Young profits from beer legislation

In Senate 18 race, Janet Cruz says Dana Young profits from beer legislation

The Janet Cruz campaign is opening a new line of attack against state District 18 Republican Sen. Dana Young, suggesting Young has sponsored legislation that benefits her husband's investments in the craft beer industry.Young has developed a reputati...
Updated: 8 hours ago
Andrew Gillums talks tighter gun control in Broward County

Andrew Gillums talks tighter gun control in Broward County

Andrew Gillum came to Broward County on Friday to raise money and talk about guns.Sheriff Scott Israel helped him with one, but not so much the other.Appearing outside his campaign's Plantation office to unveil an endorsement from gun-control group E...
Updated: 8 hours ago
NRA sway: For Florida officials, it’s always Hammer time

NRA sway: For Florida officials, it’s always Hammer time

On the Fourth of July 2016, National Rifle Association lobbyist Marion Hammer fired off an email to the Florida Department of Agriculture and Consumer Services."This crap needs to stop," begins Hammer in the first of seven emails she would exchange w...
Updated: 9 hours ago
Florida agriculture commissioner candidates tangle over debate schedule

Florida agriculture commissioner candidates tangle over debate schedule

Rep. Matt Caldwell, Republican candidate for Commissioner of Agriculture and Consumer Services, challenged his Democratic opponent on Friday morning to debate — but Fried's campaign contended they've already offered dates to debate that th...
Updated: 9 hours ago
Amid criticism of tax plan, Chris King talks small business with Colorado Governor in St. Petersburg

Amid criticism of tax plan, Chris King talks small business with Colorado Governor in St. Petersburg

John Hickenlooper found himself right at home at St. Petersburg's Flying Boat Brewery.The Democratic governor of Colorado was at establishment to participate in an informal discussion about how to grow small businesses with the Democratic n...
Updated: 9 hours ago
See all released emails between the NRA’s Marion Hammer and the Florida Department of Agriculture

See all released emails between the NRA’s Marion Hammer and the Florida Department of Agriculture

Marion Hammer, the chief lobbyist for the National Rifle Association in Florida, communicates regularly with Florida officials on everything from gun legislation to spam phone calls, a set of released emails has revealed.Read more: NRA sway; For Flor...
Published: 09/21/18
How is Florida doing after 20 years under GOP rule?

How is Florida doing after 20 years under GOP rule?

Republicans have controlled Florida’s governor’s office and Legislature since 1999.When voters consider their choice in this year’s governor’s race, how they perceive the last two decades will be critical.Are we Floridians bet...
Published: 09/21/18
DeSantis won’t return money from donor who called Obama the N-word

DeSantis won’t return money from donor who called Obama the N-word

Republican U.S. Rep. Ron DeSantis' campaign for Florida governor said Thursday he will no longer accept money from a donor who used the N-word in a tweet about former President Barack Obama, but said contributions the donor's company made won't be re...
Published: 09/21/18