Sunday, June 17, 2018
The Buzz
  • The Buzz
  • From the staff of the Tampa Bay Times

This bill would allow trafficking victims to sue hotels. Hotels don’t like it.

When Savannah Parvu was being sold for sex out of a central Florida hotel room, she was just 12 years old.

Men came in and raped her, and hotel staff asked nothing and did nothing, she told legislators on Monday.

Sometimes, her trafficker asked hotel staff for favors, asking them to open the door to let men inside. They obliged.

One night, when she didn't have a ride home from the hotel, her trafficker asked hotel staff to tell her to walk. They obliged.

"I was walking barefoot, bloody, beaten and alone at 12 years old down the hallway of the hotel," she told legislators. "Nobody helped me. No one asked questions. Nobody did anything."

Parvu's story is at the center of a debate over a bill in the Florida Legislature that would allow human trafficking victims to sue some of the businesses that most profit from it: hotels and motels.

On the surface, the bill has widespread support, passing three committees without anyone voting against it. But behind the scenes, the hotel industry is waging a campaign against it, legislators say.

"We've seen language, not from Disney directly … that would have removed some of the teeth that exist," said the senate bill sponsor, state Sen. Lauren Book, D-Plantation. When asked whether there has been a behind-the-scenes effort to weaken the bill, Book said, "I think that's a fair assumption."

The House version of the bill, sponsored by state Rep. Ross Spano, R-Dover, might be defanged. Spano filed an amendment that would exempt hotels and motels from being sued, but the amendment hasn't been taken up yet.

Neither Disney nor the Florida Restaurant and Lodging Association, which are both registered to lobby the House version of the bill, responded to requests for comment.

And no one spoke against the bill during Monday's committee hearing, in which survivors of human trafficking told horrifying stories of rape and abuse in Florida hotel rooms.

"That is where the largest percent of sex trafficking takes place," said Connie Rose, who said she was sexually abused by her father from age 2 and then forced into prostitution at age 15.

The bill would not just allow victims to sue their traffickers and "willfully blind" companies that help carry out trafficking.

If the victims win their lawsuits, their defendants would have to pay an additional $50,000 penalty, which would go to a trust fund for other victims. If police rescued the trafficking victim, an additional $50,000 would be imposed on the defendant, for other anti-trafficking efforts by police.

But the bill gives hotels an easy way to escape such lawsuits. If the hotel trains employees to recognize signs of trafficking, has a protocol for reporting it, and employees followed the training and protocols, the hotel has an "affirmative defense" that would quash the lawsuit.

Texas and Pennsylvania have adopted similar laws, and at least two lawsuits have followed. In January, a Houston teen who was trafficked filed a case against 15 hotel chains and five truck stops. Last year, a 14-year-old girl filed a lawsuit against a roadside motel in Philadelphia where she was forced to have sex with as many as 1,000 men over two years.

Former Seminole County prosecutor Lisa Haba told legislators that the signs of trafficking are obvious, and that hotel staff often know what's going on. She recalled one case she brought against a man who was trafficking a 17-year-old girl in a Days Inn.

Haba said she put the hotel manager on the stand during the trial, where the woman admitted knowing prostitution was going on, but said she was only concerned with renting rooms and paying bills.

"That girl was raped more than 10 times in one day because that woman turned a blind eye and did nothing," Haba said.

On Monday, senators were awed by the women who recounted being trafficked, even if they expressed concern about creating a new market for trial lawyers to go after hotels.

"How do we protect an industry without just telling them they're guilty before getting started?" state Sen. Doug Broxson, R-Gulf Breeze, said.

Neither Broxson nor committee chairman René Garcia, R-Hialeah, who also expressed concerns about the bill, said they were approached by anyone in  the hotel industry. Broxson did say he had heard rumors that the industry was trying to influence the bill.

"They haven't spoken to me. The concerns that I have are my concerns," Garcia said. "I could care less about the industry. My whole concern is about the victims."

Both senators voted for the bill.

Broxson called one of the women who spoke "an incredible human being" for sharing her story.

"You will be remembered forever here for being one of the greatest people we've ever seen," he said.

Comments
Florida Insider Poll finds doubt Democrats will nominate strongest candidate

Florida Insider Poll finds doubt Democrats will nominate strongest candidate

The verdict is clear among Florida's political elites as to who would be the strongest gubernatorial nominees for the general election: Democrat Gwen Graham and Republican Adam Putnam.But among more than 200 Florida political experts participating in...
Published: 06/15/18
Rick Scott fires back in election-year early voting lawsuit

Rick Scott fires back in election-year early voting lawsuit

Gov. Rick Scott's administration fired back in federal court Friday, seeking to undercut a League of Women Voters lawsuit over early voting on college campuses.The League last month sued Scott's chief elections official, Secretary of State Ken Detzne...
Published: 06/15/18

Group ramps up to elect Democrats up and down Florida ballot

A giant, union-backed political group that knocked on an estimated 3 million doors in Florida in 2016 is revving up for an even more ambitious effort this year aimed at electing Democrats up and down the ballot, passing the felon voting rights initia...
Published: 06/15/18
Nelson offered this man up for a judicial position. Now heíll vote against him.

Nelson offered this man up for a judicial position. Now heíll vote against him.

WASHINGTON – Sen. Bill Nelson said today he will vote against a judicial nominee he offered up to the White House along with Sen. Marco Rubio, a remarkable turn that raises questions about Nelson's own vetting process as he tried to put the foc...
Published: 06/15/18
State probes possible misuse of confidential driverís license info

State probes possible misuse of confidential driverís license info

State law enforcement authorities said Friday they are investigating the possible criminal misuse of confidential driver license data in a case involving a high-ranking state official."FDLE is investigating possible improper use of personal identifyi...
Published: 06/15/18
Judge sides with environmentalists, says lawmakers failed to comply with Amendment 1

Judge sides with environmentalists, says lawmakers failed to comply with Amendment 1

Striking a blow to the Legislature, a Tallahassee judge said state lawmakers failed to comply with a voter-approved constitutional amendment to buy and preserve environmentally sensitive lands.Ruling from the bench Friday, Leon County Circuit Judge C...
Published: 06/15/18
Gwen Graham files qualifying papers in run for governor

Gwen Graham files qualifying papers in run for governor

Former U.S. Rep Gwen Graham submitted qualifying paperwork in her bid for governor Friday morning, becoming the first major candidate to file officially in the statewide race.Though the official qualifying period for offices across the state is ...
Published: 06/15/18
Nelson, Rubio oppose breaking up immigrant families

Nelson, Rubio oppose breaking up immigrant families

WASHINGTON – The breakup of immigrant families at the southern border has generated significant controversy and discussion.So what do Florida Sens. Bill Nelson and Marco Rubio think?Nelson has been outspoken on the issue and has joined legislat...
Published: 06/15/18
Nelsonís payback ad highlights Scott controversies

Nelsonís payback ad highlights Scott controversies

Days after Rick Scott released an ad showing Bill Nelson aging through years of politics, Democrats are out with their own showing Scott progressing through scandal."After decades of fraud and failure, we can't send Rick Scott to the Senate," a narra...
Published: 06/15/18
Democrats oppose Florida judge despite backing from Nelson

Democrats oppose Florida judge despite backing from Nelson

TALLAHASSEE, Fla. — A Florida judge in line for a key federal post is running into opposition from Senate Democrats despite the support of Democratic U.S. Sen. Bill Nelson.A U.S. Senate committee on Thursday narrowly voted along partisan lines ...
Published: 06/15/18