Monday, January 22, 2018
The Buzz
  • The Buzz
  • From the staff of the Tampa Bay Times

Electricity choice short-circuits at CRC

A committee of the Constitution Revision Commission voted Friday to reject a proposal that would have allowed Floridians to vote on choosing their electricity provider and pushed the state's monopolized utilities to compete in selling and generating electricity.

Proposal 51, modeled after Texas' deregulation under former governor George W. Bush, would have allowed customers to buy electricity from third-party suppliers that would be able to transmit the power through lines operated by utility companies. It would have preserved utility companies' ownership of power poles and wires, but opened up the market to new parties who could generate and sell electrical power.

Five of seven members on the General Provisions Committee of the CRC voted to reject the proposal after a compromise amendment failed to pass. The amendment would have exempted some municipalities so they could continue to collect utility fees.

"This is what should be on the ballot, because people want [energy choice]," said Commissioner Rich Newsome, the proposal's sponsor, before it was voted down. "Is it gonna make a difference? Yes."

Supporters had said opening up the market would decrease utilities costs by billions of dollars, improve the economy with more jobs and new businesses, encourage innovations in renewable energy and push money into rural areas.

Advocates for the proposal had created the Florida Energy Freedom coalition and hired the Perryman Group, an economics research firm based in Waco, Texas, to analyze the proposal's potential savings. That study, said Ray Perryman, estimated Floridians could have saved about $6 billion in 2016 if the state had had a mature competitive market, and that up to 100,000 permanent jobs could be created in the next dozen years.

The retail giant Walmart also threw its support behind the bill. Chris Hendrix, director of markets and compliance for Wal-Mart Stores, Inc., had said that the proposal would save the business about $15 million per year in the state's 385 stores, based on the company's' experience in other states where electricity is priced competitively.

Opponents, supported by the state's powerful utility industry, contended that implementing the market changes would be complicated, would not save much in costs and could result in uneven service. Some groups, including the Florida Chamber of Commerce and Associated Industries of Florida — both of which receive financial support from utility companies — opposed the proposal. Groups operating on behalf of the utility industry said deregulation had had unfavorable results in other states.

"California and Texas experimented with deregulation years ago, and since then customers in those states have seen their reliability suffer, billions of dollars have been lost in bankruptcies and customer bills have gone up," said FPL spokeswoman Sarah Gatewood in a statement sent to the Herald/Times on Thursday before the final vote. "In some states, deregulation has led to price manipulation by energy suppliers, bankruptcies and the loss of thousands of high-paying local jobs. Deregulation is complicated and as we've seen in many states, getting it wrong leads to significant problems for residents and businesses within the state."

Advocates for the bill had attempted to resolve a conflict with some cities and municipalities that depend on collecting utilities fees by compromising on an amendment that would exempt such areas from electricity deregulation. But the amendment, which was supported by organizations including the Florida League of Cities and the Florida Association of Counties, failed on a 3-3 tie.

Rep. Jeanette Núñez, R-Miami, did not vote because she had to step out for her pre-session responsibilities as speaker pro tempore of the House, though she said she would have voted no on the amendment regardless.

"The voters elected me to do the job of representative. … I decided to prioritize my voters in that particular moment," she said, after she returned for the vote on the full proposal. She said she was opposed to using the constitutional revision process for such proposals.

"I have that legislative mentality in terms of, what is something that is a legislative process or a legislative bill, versus something that is constitutional in nature?" Núñez added.

Rick Blaser, who proposed the idea at a CRC public hearing and founded an energy company in Gainesville, said the Florida Energy Freedom coalition will now regroup and reconsider paths forward for the proposal, including a bill currently in the Senate that would establish a task force to project the state's electric energy needs and potential new policies, or a ballot initiative, though that path would be expensive.

"It's clear that there is growing public interest and demand for electricity freedom so Florida consumers can choose their own electricity providers," the Florida Energy Freedom coalition said in a statement. "We are near a tipping point on this issue and will continue to make the case to the public, business community, and Florida Legislature."

Newsome said he still considers the proposal "inevitable," though he expressed disappointment in Friday's outcome.

"Perhaps the power lobby with their money can stave this off for a while, but as technologies continue to improve, and the concerns about climate change and renewable energy continues to gather momentum, I think it's just a matter of time," Newsome said.

Miami Herald Tallahassee bureau chief Mary Ellen Klas contributed to this report.

Comments
Nursing homes need improved emergency plans. But who will verify them?

Nursing homes need improved emergency plans. But who will verify them?

Two months before a dozen residents died in sweltering heat at the Rehabilitation Center at Hollywood Hills, the now-shuttered nursing home submitted a plan to county administrators to show the facility could handle crises like a missing resident or ...
Updated: 2 hours ago
Robocall hits Bill Nelson over shutdown

Robocall hits Bill Nelson over shutdown

WASHINGTON – Republicans have unleashed a new attack on Sen. Bill Nelson with a robo call saying he "recklessly voted to shut down the United States government.""It is infuriating, it is petty, and YOU deserve better from your elected official,...
Updated: 12 hours ago
Losers of the week in Florida politics

Losers of the week in Florida politics

Loser of the weekRick Scott. Donald Trump did him a giant favor by reversing course on a plan to expand offshore drilling off Florida's Gulf Coast, but now the governor's inconsistent positions on drilling are under scrutiny as he declines to say whe...
Published: 01/21/18
Shutdown politics: Nelson weighs in with another reason for his vote

Shutdown politics: Nelson weighs in with another reason for his vote

WASHINGTON – Sen. Bill Nelson on Sunday offered "another reason" for his vote against the short-term budget, underscoring the delicate politics of the shutdown."Another reason I voted against the Continuing Resolution Friday night was that it o...
Published: 01/21/18
GOP targets Nelson with shutdown ad

GOP targets Nelson with shutdown ad

WASHINGTON – Republicans on Saturday targeted Sen. Bill Nelson with an online ad that blamed Democrats for the shutdown.The NRSC ad, which will appear on Facebook, focuses on child health care, military funding and other issues held up by the s...
Published: 01/20/18
Government shutdown partially shuts down some Florida parks

Government shutdown partially shuts down some Florida parks

EVERGLADES CITY, Fla. — The federal government shutdown will partially close Big Cypress National Preserve, Everglades National Park and other federally managed natural areas in Florida.The Naples Daily News reports that the western gateway to ...
Published: 01/20/18
Trump plans gala at Mar-a-Lago on Saturday night, again renting a ballroom from himself

Trump plans gala at Mar-a-Lago on Saturday night, again renting a ballroom from himself

PALM BEACH, Fla. – President Donald Trump's posh Mar-a-Lago Club is set to host a high-priced gala Saturday night intended to celebrate Trump's first year in office and raise money for his reelection campaign and the Republican National Committ...
Published: 01/20/18
Rubio and Nelson split votes as government goes into shutdown

Rubio and Nelson split votes as government goes into shutdown

WASHINGTON – Florida Sen. Bill Nelson joined a majority of Democrats and some Republicans to defeat the short-term spending plan passed by the House, while Sen. Marco Rubio voted for the measure."These short-term funding bills are hurting our n...
Published: 01/20/18
State Rep. Kathleen Peters withdraws application for spot on the Public Service Commission

State Rep. Kathleen Peters withdraws application for spot on the Public Service Commission

Rep. Kathleen Peters has taken herself out of the running for a spot on the Public Service Commission.Peters, who in 2017 decided to run for a spot on the Pinellas County Commission rather than seek another term in the State House, announce...
Published: 01/20/18
Florida braces for long government shutdown

Florida braces for long government shutdown

As a dysfunctional Washington stumbled past the midnight deadline and into a shutdown of the federal government, state officials scrambled to prepare for its impacts across Florida.Many aspects of life involve the federal government, from Everglades ...
Published: 01/19/18
Updated: 01/20/18